Comments on: Ideas for html5gallery http://html5gallery.com A showcase of sites using HTML5 markup Fri, 03 Feb 2012 21:41:06 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3 By: Brianhttp://html5gallery.com/ideas/comment-page-1/#comment-21485 Brian Fri, 12 Aug 2011 05:55:25 +0000 http://html5gallery.com/?page_id=165#comment-21485 Great site guys, thanks for the share. It's good to see what other people are doing with HTML5 Such an exciting move for web designers ! Hooray for HTML5 ! Great site guys, thanks for the share. It’s good to see what other people are doing with HTML5 Such an exciting move for web designers ! Hooray for HTML5 !

]]> By: Paulo Marqueshttp://html5gallery.com/ideas/comment-page-1/#comment-3759 Paulo Marques Thu, 27 Jan 2011 20:29:57 +0000 http://html5gallery.com/?page_id=165#comment-3759 First, i think that's a good idea, but the criterious to submit a page are a litle irrelevant. I see some codes an they have i little of html5, not the entire development of the content. First, i think that’s a good idea, but the criterious to submit a page are a litle irrelevant.

I see some codes an they have i little of html5, not the entire development of the content.

]]> By: Dan Walshhttp://html5gallery.com/ideas/comment-page-1/#comment-2841 Dan Walsh Tue, 14 Dec 2010 14:34:44 +0000 http://html5gallery.com/?page_id=165#comment-2841 Yep, thanks for the reply. Yep, thanks for the reply.

]]> By: Richard Clarkhttp://html5gallery.com/ideas/comment-page-1/#comment-2770 Richard Clark Fri, 10 Dec 2010 16:35:46 +0000 http://html5gallery.com/?page_id=165#comment-2770 @Art, we're going to be looking at a (long overdue) redesign and rebrand in the new year so a ratings filter is something that we'll look into. The option to filter by category or tag already exists; just click on them! @Dan, you're right there is a long wait at the moment, we do have four of us curating the site and posting as much as we can. As I'm sure you can appreciate we all do this when spare time allows which isn't always easy with families etc. We've also purposefully decided not to make the process automated to ensure each site gets valuable critique. We're currently processing some sites that were submitted in September. You're right a time indication is probably a good idea for something to add. I did used to email folks make when their site was rejected but this no longer happens because of time. I also found that no-one tended to reply with "ok, I understand, I'll improve it" rather they didn't reply at all. Hopefully that addresses your concerns. @Art, we’re going to be looking at a (long overdue) redesign and rebrand in the new year so a ratings filter is something that we’ll look into.

The option to filter by category or tag already exists; just click on them!

@Dan, you’re right there is a long wait at the moment, we do have four of us curating the site and posting as much as we can. As I’m sure you can appreciate we all do this when spare time allows which isn’t always easy with families etc.

We’ve also purposefully decided not to make the process automated to ensure each site gets valuable critique. We’re currently processing some sites that were submitted in September. You’re right a time indication is probably a good idea for something to add.

I did used to email folks make when their site was rejected but this no longer happens because of time. I also found that no-one tended to reply with “ok, I understand, I’ll improve it” rather they didn’t reply at all.

Hopefully that addresses your concerns.

]]> By: Dan Walshhttp://html5gallery.com/ideas/comment-page-1/#comment-2768 Dan Walsh Fri, 10 Dec 2010 15:55:51 +0000 http://html5gallery.com/?page_id=165#comment-2768 This isn't intended to be a rant/sour grapes so I hope it doesn't come across that way but...I submitted my site quite a while ago and check back every day to see if it's been listed. When I find it hasn't I shrug my shoulders and think 'Oh well, try again tomorrow'. Call me impatient but what would be useful is an estimated time of listing - assuming my site is worthy of being listed, of course! Also, if a site is submitted and fails to be listed perhaps an indication of why it wasn't listed would be helpful. Although I apreciate you may not have the time to provide this type of feedback. Anyway, that's my tuppence worth. Overall, it's a great site, it's been a real help to me and really inspiring so thank you. This isn’t intended to be a rant/sour grapes so I hope it doesn’t come across that way but…I submitted my site quite a while ago and check back every day to see if it’s been listed. When I find it hasn’t I shrug my shoulders and think ‘Oh well, try again tomorrow’. Call me impatient but what would be useful is an estimated time of listing – assuming my site is worthy of being listed, of course!

Also, if a site is submitted and fails to be listed perhaps an indication of why it wasn’t listed would be helpful. Although I apreciate you may not have the time to provide this type of feedback.

Anyway, that’s my tuppence worth. Overall, it’s a great site, it’s been a real help to me and really inspiring so thank you.

]]> By: Art_Hellhttp://html5gallery.com/ideas/comment-page-1/#comment-2744 Art_Hell Wed, 08 Dec 2010 22:04:46 +0000 http://html5gallery.com/?page_id=165#comment-2744 I like the idea of the search or filter on ratings. However, I would say have another rating for code. Combined scoring filters the "Champs". Where I have little to no experience or talent with the code I would NOT rate anyone. However someone that liked the code and knew it well enough to rate it might enlighten me on code that is truly exceptional. Additionally consider the the option to filter on the class or descriptor Agency, Blog, Agency, or Education. There by allow a novice, as I am, to filter a few good examples of the type I am looking for so I might actually make a decent page. I like the idea of the search or filter on ratings. However, I would say have another rating for code. Combined scoring filters the “Champs”. Where I have little to no experience or talent with the code I would NOT rate anyone. However someone that liked the code and knew it well enough to rate it might enlighten me on code that is truly exceptional. Additionally consider the the option to filter on the class or descriptor Agency, Blog, Agency, or Education.

There by allow a novice, as I am, to filter a few good examples of the type I am looking for so I might actually make a decent page.

]]> By: Richard Clarkhttp://html5gallery.com/ideas/comment-page-1/#comment-2341 Richard Clark Mon, 27 Sep 2010 13:10:36 +0000 http://html5gallery.com/?page_id=165#comment-2341 @ksrich - Searching by ratings is a good idea and something that we'll look into, the problem is lots of folk only vote on the visual not on the best code which needs some further thinking. @ksrich – Searching by ratings is a good idea and something that we’ll look into, the problem is lots of folk only vote on the visual not on the best code which needs some further thinking.

]]> By: Ksrichhttp://html5gallery.com/ideas/comment-page-1/#comment-2293 Ksrich Tue, 21 Sep 2010 15:41:06 +0000 http://html5gallery.com/?page_id=165#comment-2293 I personally like the ratings, but wish there was a way to search by rating to see who has the best code, rather than look through everyone. I personally like the ratings, but wish there was a way to search by rating to see who has the best code, rather than look through everyone.

]]> By: Ian Devlinhttp://html5gallery.com/ideas/comment-page-1/#comment-2159 Ian Devlin Fri, 03 Sep 2010 16:49:38 +0000 http://html5gallery.com/?page_id=165#comment-2159 Why have I only seen the messages regarding a meetup with Bruce and Rich now? Only 5 months too late! Why have I only seen the messages regarding a meetup with Bruce and Rich now? Only 5 months too late!

]]> By: Richard Clarkhttp://html5gallery.com/ideas/comment-page-1/#comment-2064 Richard Clark Mon, 16 Aug 2010 12:08:46 +0000 http://html5gallery.com/?page_id=165#comment-2064 @Carl, thanks for the feeback. Throwing stones isn't our objective. We aim to provide constructive critique of peoples work, as many developers find getting their heads around HTML5 hard work. Rather than simply posting up screenshots of the latest design we spend time delving into the mark-up to see how it could be improved. As explained on the <a href="http://html5gallery.com/about/" rel="nofollow">about page</a> and in the footer of each page, the site is built on the back of a theme from WooThemes and hasn't yet been converted to HTML5. It will be when I get time. This site is run in my spare time along with several other projects I've got going it perhaps doesn't get the attention it deserves. Hope that explanation helps a litte. Rich @Carl, thanks for the feeback. Throwing stones isn’t our objective. We aim to provide constructive critique of peoples work, as many developers find getting their heads around HTML5 hard work. Rather than simply posting up screenshots of the latest design we spend time delving into the mark-up to see how it could be improved.

As explained on the about page and in the footer of each page, the site is built on the back of a theme from WooThemes and hasn’t yet been converted to HTML5. It will be when I get time. This site is run in my spare time along with several other projects I’ve got going it perhaps doesn’t get the attention it deserves.

Hope that explanation helps a litte.

Rich

]]>